Josie’s Pizza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Josie’s Pizza, your ultimate destination for Columbus-style pizza! Located at 894 W Broad St, this vibrant eatery offers a dynamic menu that caters to every pizza lover's dream. From their classic Cheese Pizza made with a blend of mozzarella and provolone to the indulgent Meat Lovers Pizza, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Each pizza is crafted using a family recipe sauce, ensuring a delightful blend of flavors.
But that’s not all—Josie’s also features unique offerings like the B.L.T. Pizza topped with fresh ingredients, and hearty Submarines such as the traditional Italian sub and their flavor-packed Meatball Sub. Don’t miss out on dessert; indulge in their Chewy Gooey Chocolate Cookie for a sweet finish! With options for takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating, Josie’s Pizza promises a fantastic dining experience for families and groups alike.
Our Desserts
NEW Chewy Gooey Chocolate Cookie
Mouthwatering, chewy, gooey, and so chocolaty! Try out our NEW 8 inch chocolate cookie!
Custom Pizza
Build your own pizza! Make it taste as good as you can make it!
Pepperoni Pizza
Our normal pepperoni pizza has the pepperoni underneath the cheese, which adds flavor to our family sauce. A great classic fit for almost everyone!(Pepperoni are under cheese, they can be added on top)
Original Pepperoni Pizza
Our original pepperoni sits on top of the cheese. Otherwise known as old world pepperoni. Always a nice greasy bite!
Cheese Pizza
Our classic cheese pizza uses a great blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, with our family recipe sauce, and cooked in our classic stone ovens!
B.L.T. Pizza
Our B.L.T. pizza comes with our classic bacon, and once cooked, gets topped with our fresh shredded lettuce and fresh cut tomatoes. (Smalls get one pack of Ranch. Larges get two packs of Ranch)
Hawaiian Pizza
Wanna feel like your in Hawaii? Then this pizza will bring you their. Getting topped with Ham, Bacon and the final piece, Pineapple.
Meat Lovers Pizza
This Pizza is one of the big ones, the Meat lover! Getting topped with, pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, bacon, and ham.
Combination Pizza
Our classic Combination, coming with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, fresh cut onions and fresh cut green pepper.
Supreme Pizza
This is a big one, the pizza the comes with almost ever thing on it, our classic Supreme, topped with pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive and banana pepper.
Garlic Pizza Bread
Our classic garlic pizza bread service on a 10" pie or 14" pie. Enough for everyone! With garlic sauce, cheese and oregano.
Veggie Pizza
Topped with fresh cut green peppers, cut onions, mushrooms, hot peppers and black olives.
Our Columbus Style Pizza
Our Submarines (9" Aldino's Bun)
Italian Sub.
Our traditional Italian sub comes with fresh cut Capocollo Ham, salami, provolone cheese. Topped with lettuce, tomatoes, banana pepper & onions. Italian dressing is optional, for additional charge.
Super Italian Sub
Our traditional Italian sub, but double the fresh cut capocollo ham, salami, provolone cheese. Topped with lettuce, tomatoes, banana pepper & onions.Topped with lettuce, tomatoes, banana pepper & onions. Italian dressing is optional, for additional charge.
Chicken Sub
Our chicken sub is served with two deep fried chicken patty, along with American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, banana pepper, and onion.
Chicken Parm Sub
Our Chicken Parm Sub is served with two deep fried chicken patty, along with cheese, our sauce.
Stromboli Sub
Our version of a stromboli is a tasty "steak patty or a hoagie patty" put onto a buttered toasted bun, with cheese and veggies on it. it comes with the lettuce, tomatoes, banana pepper, and onion.
Double Stromboli
This version of a stromboli is double the meat! With a tasty "steak patty or a hoagie patty" put onto a buttered toasted bun, with cheese and veggies on it. it comes with the lettuce, tomatoes, banana pepper, and onion.
Meatball Sub
For our classic meatball sub it will come with 4 meatballs, with sauce and provolone cheese.
Veggie Sub
Our veggie sub offers extra veggies on our classic sub buns, lettuce, tomato, hot peppers and onions.
Mild Wings
You get 6 or 12 of our traditional Tyson bone-in chicken wings that have a nice juicy taste when you bit into them. They are a dry wings.
Inferno Wings
You get 6 or 12 of our traditional Tyson bone-in chicken wings that have a nice kick when you take a bit. they are a dry wings.
Chicken Fritters
Enjoy our Chicken Fritters with a side of dipping sauce (Per 3 fritters)
Chicken Tenders
Enjoy 6 or 12 of our juicy chicken tender that always hit the spot! (Check out dinners for meal options.)
5 Pieces Cheese Sticks
Enjoy 5 of our mozzarella cheese sticks with a side of our classic pizza sauce. One side of pizza sauce is included.
6 Pieces Broccoli and Cheese Poppers
Broccoli cut up mixed with cheddar cheese served inside a breaded shell, a mouth watering 6 awaits you!
4 Pieces Jalapeno Poppers
Get a total of 4 massive breaded Jalapeno popper packed with cream cheese with a bread shell.
Breaded Mushrooms
Multiple sizes but tons of juicy mushroom flavor with it wrapped in breaded shell.
Batter Onion Rings
Get a bag full of crispy batter Onion rings!
Steak Cut French Fries
Get a bag full of chefs cut steak fries!
Our Appetizers
Our Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Just like grandma made it! Two buttered and toasted pieces bread with 2 slices of American Cheese.
Texas Toast Grilled Cheese
Our Texas Toast grilled cheese comes 2 thick slices of buttered toasted bread with American cheese, and provolone cheese.
Chicken Sandwich
You get a piece of our juicy chicken breast on a butter toasted bun, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, banana pepper and American cheese.
Cheeseburger
Classic cheeseburger with a toasted bun served with lettuce, tomatoes, onion and pickle.
Double Cheeseburger
Classic cheeseburger but let's make it 2 patties and more cheese! With a toasted bun served with lettuce, tomatoes, onion and pickle.
Hamburger
Classic beef hamburger, on a toasted bun served with lettuce, tomatoes, onion and pickle.
Double Hamburger
Classic hamburger but let's make it 2 patties! Between a toasted bun served with lettuce, tomatoes, onion and pickle.
Meatball Sandwich
Get 2 meaty meatballs on a butter toasted bun with provolone cheese on top.
BBQ Sandwich
A great tasting BBQ, with cooked beef, put in between a butter toasted bun.
Spaghetti & Meatballs Dinner
Classic Spaghetti sauce, noodles & 1.5" meatballs served with a small tossed salad, and a Aldino's Bakery dinner roll. Meatballs due contain pork.
Chicken Tender Dinner
Our Chicken Tender dinner is served with 6 juicy tenders, french fries, with a small tossed salad, and a Aldino's Bakery dinner roll.
Chicken Parmesan & Spaghetti Dinner
Our Chicken Parmesan dinner is served with a juicy fried piece of chicken, with spaghetti noodles and sauce, topped with cheese. With a small tossed salad, and a Aldino's Bakery dinner roll.
Chicken Fritter Dinner
Get our Chicken fritter dinner is served with 3 juicy fritters, french fries, with a small tossed salad, and a Aldino's Bakery dinner roll.
Our Dinners
Our Salads
Italian Chef Salad
Our iconic chef salad comes with fresh iceberg lettuce, hand cut tomatoes, banana pepper, cut onions, our chef meat. Chef meat is, cut up capacolla ham, salami, pepperoni provolone cheese, American cheese, pizza cheese. Comes with packs dressings as well.
Chicken Salad
Our tasty chicken salad comes with fresh iceberg lettuce, hand cut tomatoes, banana pepper, cut onions, and a breaded chicken patty, Comes with three packs dressings as well.
Tossed Salad
Our tossed salad comes with just iceberg lettuce and fresh cut tomatoes. Comes with dressing packet for the small and two for the large.
Extra Ranch Packet
Marzetti dressings 1.5 oz. Gluten free.
Extra Blue Cheese Packet
Marzetti dressings 1.5 oz. Gluten free.
Extra Honey French Packet
Marzetti dressings 1.5 oz. Gluten free.
Extra Italian Packet
Marzetti dressings 1.5 oz. Gluten free.
Extra Light-Italian Packet
Marzetti dressings 1.5 oz. Gluten free.
Side of Pickles
Cup full of our hamburger pickles.
Side of Honey Mustard
Marzetti honey mustard 1.0 oz. Gluten free
Extra Thousand Island Packet
Marzetti dressings 1.5 oz. Gluten free.
Extra BBQ Sauce
Additional Items
Heart Pizzas
Heart Pizza
This Heart pizza is a whole topping. First topping is in the price.
Half and Half Heart
For anyone who wants their own side! Cut out of our 14 inch large shell. The First topping is in the price for the left side!
Cheesey Heart
Just a plain and simple cheese heart!